<p>The answers in this Q&amp;A <a href="https://stats.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4436/does-unanimity-of-reasons-to-close-matter">Does unanimity of reasons to close matter?</a> throw light on the related issue of whether the reasons for closure matter. The short answer is - they do not. </p>

<p>In the case of the question at issue here it seems from the comments that it falls into a common group of questions where the OP has found something unexpected and seeks enlightenment. This could be a failure of statistical understanding which is clearly on-topic or a problem with data or code. In the latter case it might be on-topic if statistical knowledge is required to answer.</p>
